Add or Drop a Product Line (or Segment)

Some product lines or business segments tend to under-perform compared to others.

In deciding whether to add a new product line or drop an existing one, the management must consider relevant benefits and costs.

As a rule, product lines or business segments should be evaluated based on traceable revenues and costs. Allocated fixed costs should be removed from the analysis of income since the company will incur in the entire amount with or without the product line or segment.

Example

XYZ Company has three product lines. The company is considering dropping Product 2 because it has been operating at a loss. The following summarizes the income of the three product lines.

 
Product 1
 
Product 2
 
Product 3
 
Total
Sales
$15,000
 
$22,000
 
$37,000
 
$74,000
Less: Variable Costs
9,000
 
10,000
 
19,000
 
38,000
Contribution Margin
$ 6,000
 
$12,000
 
$18,000
 
$36,000
Less: Fixed Costs              
Traceable
3,000
 
10,000
 
6,000
 
19,000
Allocated
1,000
 
3,500
 
5,000
 
9,500
Net Income
$ 2,000
 
($ 1,500)
 
$ 7,000
 
$ 7,500

Solution:

The allocated fixed costs should be removed when analyzing segment income. Hence, Product 2 should not be dropped since it has a positive segment margin.

 
Product 1
 
Product 2
 
Product 3
Sales
$15,000
 
$22,000
 
$37,000
Less: Variable Costs
9,000
 
10,000
 
19,000
Contribution Margin
$ 6,000
 
$12,000
 
$18,000
Less: Traceable Fixed Costs
3,000
 
10,000
 
6,000
Segment Income
$ 3,000
 
$ 2,500
 
$ 12,000

Why are we removing the allocated fixed costs in our analysis? Because the company would still incur the entire allocated fixed costs with or without Product 2. A portion of these costs is actually absorbed by Product 2's segment income. If Product 2 is dropped, it will result in lesser overall profits.

 
With Product 2
 
Without Product 2
Sales
$74,000
 
$52,000
Less: Variable Costs
38,000
 
28,000
Contribution Margin
$36,000
 
$24,000
Less: Fixed Costs      
Traceable
19,000
 
9,000
Allocated
9,500
 
9,500
Net Income
$ 7,500
 
$ 5,500

The allocated fixed costs are unavoidable costs. The entire $9,500 would be incurred with or without Product 2. If Product 2 is dropped, it will result in lower overall net income. Hence, the product line should not be dropped.

Online resource for all things accounting. more
Search this Site
Featured in the Blog
Feedback
Questions, comments and suggestions?
Contact us here.
Copyright © 2016 Accountingverse.com - Your Online Resource For All Things Accounting
Terms of Use | Home | About | Contact